The price wasn’t bad… but this is dollar store levels of quality.
Brown pigment had lots of red. Cleaning or touching it up makes your eye look red and irritated. Not great but it’s passable.
The one star is directly because you cannot accurately use the tip of the applicator. The product doesn’t come out of the tip effectively, what does feels like build-up. You have to use the side of the brush- not great for lightly or accurately placing eyeliner on the inner corner or getting a sharp wing. The next reason is because the formula flakes. Small chunks of dried eyeliner literally in my eye and stuck in my eyelashes.
For the price point of $9.99, I’d expect something better than dollar tree levels of quality… and to be honest I’ve gotten better quality from dollar store eyeliners. I wanted to like this product but I think this might very well be the worst eyeliner I’ve ever used.